Great, sturdy boots — can be tough on the feet, though!
These boots are great! The material is pliable and breathable without sacrificing structure or durability. They also remain tall-looking even on tall people — I'm 5'11" and they hit right where I wanted them to. I'm usually a women's 12 and a size 10 worked great for me.
On the downside, these ate the absolute HELL out of my heels!!! I've broken in many a pair of leather boots and never got raw blisters like I got from these guys. This sucks, because now I have to wait to wear them a second time!
Since blistering is not totally unexpected with shoes like these (and because I love how they look and feel otherwise), they still get a high rating from me. I'd recommend breaking them in with thick socks and moleskin/blister pads/bandaids.
Rated 0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2, where minus 2 is Runs Small, 0 is True to Size and 2 is Runs Big